/Library/InputManagers
Posted November 1st, 2007 @ 03:12pm by Erik J. Barzeski
I hadn't noticed this subtle shift in the way Leopard "wishes" people to handle Input Managers until I noticed Speed Download's "For Leopard 10.5 ONLY" folder. It contains a readme telling people to run a script that does in part:
sudo cp -pR "$BASE_PATH" /Library/InputManagers sudo cp -pR "$BASE_PLUGIN_PATH" /Library/Internet\ Plug-Ins sudo chown -R root:admin /Library/InputManagers rm -rf ~/Library/InputManagers/SpeedDownload\ Enhancer rm -rf ~/Library/Internet\ Plug-Ins/SpeedDownload\ Browser\ Plugin.plugin
My /Library/InputManagers/ folder currently contains four items:
- 1PasswdIM
- Ecamm
- Inquisitor
- SpeedDownload Enhancer
Three of them are registered products. Two add buttons and/or somewhat confusing functionality to Safari ((Inquisitor adds functionality, but doesn't really change Safari's behavior much at all.)), the system's default browser and the one all users on my computer are likely to use.
I don't want the other users on my system to have to deal with Speed Download launching or wondering what that "keyhole button" does, nor should they be nagged to purchase something they've never installed themselves.
So who's to blame here? Apple for failing to let people use ~/Library/InputManagers or the developers themselves for abusing something that's not intended for these purposes?
Donate Life
Posted 01 Nov 2007 at 4:36pm #
[...] which will certainly help with the potential threat of malware spreading this way, but, as Erik points out, comes with the non-negligible downside that all installed InputManagers affect every user. They [...]
Posted 01 Nov 2007 at 5:40pm #
Input managers are going away. Don't be surprised if they're not in 10.6 at all. They're already unsupported for 64-bit processes in 10.5 (and for anything running as root or group wheel).
This "allow them if they're owned by root and installed systemwide" setup is a compromise. Some seeds of Leopard disabled input managers completely. But people complained too much, so they put them back in, but with enough restrictions that it's hard for a user to accidentally end up with them installed.
Posted 01 Nov 2007 at 6:39pm #
[quote comment="44131"]Input managers are going away. Don't be surprised if they're not in 10.6 at all.[/quote]
I know - which makes their "promotion" to system-wide use and root ownership all the more confusing in 10.5.
[quote comment="44131"] but with enough restrictions that it's hard for a user to accidentally end up with them installed.[/quote]
Ah, but now, users who never actually installed them are "forced" to use them.